Fisheries Research Articles
Trade-off assessments between reading cost and accuracy measures for digital camera monitoring of recreational boating effort
Document Type
Article
Publication Date
10-2-2020
Journal Title
Fisheries Research
ISSN
0165-7836
Keywords
a posteriori study, Jackknife re-sampling draws, Recreational vessels, Boating traffic, Sampling designs
Disciplines
Aquaculture and Fisheries | Marine Biology
Abstract
Digital camera monitoring is increasingly being used to monitor recreational fisheries. The manual interpretation of video imagery can be costly and time consuming. In an a posteriori analysis, we investigated trade-offs between the reading cost and accuracy measures of estimates of boat retrievals obtained at various sampling proportions for low, moderate and high traffic boat ramps in Western Australia. Simple random sampling, systematic sampling and stratified sampling designs with proportional and weighted allocation were evaluated to assess trade-offs in terms of bias, accuracy, precision, coverage rate and cost in estimating the annual total number of powerboat retrievals in 10,000 jackknife resampling draws. The relative standard error (RSE ± standard deviations) obtained by the sampling designs for sampling proportions from 0.4 onwards were below a 20 % threshold for three of the sampling designs across the three boat ramps. Coverage rates of over 90 % were observed for the confidence intervals for the estimated annual number of powerboat retrievals, with low relative standard errors (RSE < 20 %). Interpreting 40 % of camera footage within a year provided the minimum level to obtain sufficient accuracy measures for all sampling designs considered. The stratified random sampling design with weighted allocation consistently resulted in the smallest variance for estimates of annual powerboat retrievals across the various sampled proportions. These findings have the potential to considerably reduce the cost of manual data interpretation, since operating cost increased linearly with increasing sampling proportion.
Recommended Citation
Afrifa-Yamoah, E,
Taylor, S M,
and
Mueller, U A.
(2020), Trade-off assessments between reading cost and accuracy measures for digital camera monitoring of recreational boating effort. Fisheries Research, 233 (105757).
https://library.dpird.wa.gov.au/fr_fja/125
